
Pay-As-You-Drive Insurance: Is Usage-Based Car Cover Worth It?
QUICK SUMMARY
Pay-as-you-drive insurance links part of your car premium to the kilometres you drive. This guide explains who gains the most, how telematics tracking works, how to estimate your annual mileage and choose a slab, and when a normal comprehensive policy is the better choice.
A lot of city drivers park their cars for the majority of the week. The car is driven out for weekends, a day at the office now and again, or a family errand. However, the insurance cost is the same as that of a car that travels thousands of kilometres a month.
Pay-as-you-drive insurance attempts to remedy that imbalance. It ties a portion of your premium to the amount of driving you actually do, meaning that a car that stays in the garage is cheaper to insure than a car that's in traffic. For the right driver it can save real money. For the wrong one it increases paperwork and risk.
This guide covers what pay-as-you-drive insurance is, who benefits the most, what tracking entails, and how to compare the numbers before you switch. If you are comparing, first read our overview of motor insurance.
How Usage-Based Coverage Affects Your Own Damage Premium
There are two components to a normal comprehensive policy. The third-party part is mandatory and determined by the regulator. Own damage premium includes the cost to repair or replace your own vehicle, and is based on the value, age and location of the vehicle, as well as your claim history. The mileage has minimal impact on the cost.
The second part is pay-as-you-drive insurance. The own damage premium is tied to the kilometres driven or expected to be driven per year, and the lower the kilometres driven annually, the lower the own damage premium. The third party part remains mandatory and is not based on use, thus the saving is only on the own damage side.
This is something to keep in mind when shopping for quotes. Typically, the headline discount of a usage-based plan applies to the own damage portion, rather than the entire bill. Before you make your decision, ask the insurer to provide you with the total premium (including third-party cover and add-ons) with and without the usage-based option.
The plan is also different from the traditional policy in practice. You might have to report an annual distance, choose a slab, or let the insurer monitor mileage via the odometer, an app or a device. Understand how each option works, as the details will impact your savings and risk. Before switching, consult with a Simpli Insure advisor if you need assistance comparing quotes.
A Brief Checklist Is Helpful
Record the mileage on your car today, the mileage you drove last year, and the cost of your last car insurance renewal. These three numbers will let you know in a flash if a usage-based plan can save you money. Take a picture of the odometer reading on the date the policy goes into effect, as this will be important if there is any dispute. Place the policy schedule with the photograph for easy access. Repeat at each renewal. If the insurer has an app, screenshot the initial reading too.
Who Benefits: Low-Mileage Drivers and Remote Workers
The usage-based cover is based on a pattern: an underused car that is owned. That's a pattern that's more prevalent than many realize, particularly in urban areas where public transit, ride-hailing and remote work have reduced driving. You might already be the customer that these plans were designed for if you leave your car in the parking lot on weekdays.
The natural customers are low-mileage drivers – those with an annual mileage of a few thousand kilometres. According to a report on AutoCar Professional by Policybazaar, an estimated 15-20% of customers switched to pay-as-you-drive policies in FY26, especially those who drive less than 10,000 km annually and live in urban areas. Use that as a rough estimate, not an official statistic, from one distributor.
The estimate also provides an insight into the market. When one in five or one in six customers is opting for a usage-based product, insurers will continue to make enhancements to the product and the tracking of it. It's a good thing for buyers, but it also means that terms are evolving rapidly. Last year's feature may not be offered this year, and a discount offered today may be less at renewal. Review the current wording annually and never take anything for granted – the terms of your first policy will not necessarily be the same as your current one.
The customer profile has also changed. According to AutoCar Professional, hybrid and remote workers make up the largest share of pay-as-you-drive customers at 35% of the base, and IRDAI has announced guidelines for insurers to provide pay-as-you-drive plans as a first option. Homemakers and multi-car households are cited in the same article as growing groups
Consider the group to which you belong. It can benefit a remote worker who drives a few hundred kilometres per month, a household that has a second car that isn't used very often, or a retiree who drives locally. A sales executive or a ride-share driver or someone with a long commute will typically not save much or any money.
Be Truthful About Your Driving
Weekend trips and holidays are cumulative and people don't realize how much they are travelling. Don't rely on memory for last year's odometer reading, and allow for planned driving, or the savings may disappear the first time you hit the road.
Telematics: What Is Tracked and What It Means for You
Some usage-based plans are based on the use of telematics, or a small device, an app or the car's own connected system that tracks distance and, in some cases, driving habits. According to Outlook Business, Zuno's India Road Safety Report 2026 states that an analysis of 4.5 million trips showed driving behaviour is a bigger driver of risk than demographics, and IRDAI has allowed experimentation by introducing sandbox initiatives and frameworks for pay-as-you-drive and behaviour-linked models.
That's important because pay-as-you-drive insurance is the most basic model, based on distance, while behaviour-linked insurance takes into account how you drive – speed, braking and time of day. A driver who is careful will get a better price, but a careless driver will not. Before you sign, find out what kind of plan you're purchasing.
Inquire about what the insurer gathers and how it utilizes the information. Does it just have to do with distance or location and driving style as well? Who is able to see it, how long is it stored for and can it be deleted? Read the privacy terms, as telematics data is personal and a lower premium isn't worth giving away without knowing exactly what you're giving away.
Be Aware of the Repercussions of Tampering
The policy can be invalidated or a claim denied if the app, device or odometer is interfered with. If the tracking doesn't work, notify the insurance company in writing immediately, and retain a copy.
How to Calculate Your Annual Mileage and Select a Slab
The key to pay-as-you-drive insurance is getting the annual mileage right. Business Standard recommends that readers take care to estimate the annual mileage accurately, select the appropriate slab and review the top-up conditions. According to its annual report, Policybazaar has seen premiums on usage-based plans on its platform increase sevenfold since FY2022-23, with pay-as-you-drive covers leading the way.
Work out your number in three steps. First, get the odometer readings from last year at the beginning and end of the year. Second, include trips you already know are coming: a family wedding, holiday drive or change of job. Third, add a safety margin of 10-20%. The outcome is your annual mileage and which slab fits.
The band of distance that your premium is based on is the slab. If the slab is too small, you will be using up your kilometres too soon, and will be forced to pay for a top-up – which could cost more per kilometre. If the slab is too big, it is a waste of the saving. Ask what will happen if you go over the limit, whether there is a penalty and how much it will cost.
Read the Rest of the Policy as Well
Verify that the plan contains all the same extras you would find in a regular policy, like roadside assistance and zero depreciation, and that the claims process is the same. A lower premium policy with less coverage is not a true saving.
When It Is Not Worth It
Pay-as-you-drive insurance isn't suitable for everyone. The savings are less for the person who drives more kilometres than a modest amount per year than they are for low-mileage drivers, and the risk of running out of slab is greater. A normal comprehensive policy is better for drivers who make frequent long-distance journeys, as it has no distance limit and no tracking.
The legal minimum remains unchanged. Business Today says third party insurance is mandatory, but does not protect against damage to your own car, so a usage-based insurance policy with own damage cover is still a comprehensive policy in another guise. Avoid reducing your own damage coverage to save money, as a fire or flood could cost you much more than the premium you save.
Also consider convenience. A standard policy might be easier if you don't like apps or devices, or if you have multiple family members who drive varying distances. Saving a few thousand rupees is not worth a policy you don't understand.
Bottom Line: Pay for the Kilometres That You Actually Drive
Pay-as-you-drive insurance is perfect for those who drive very little. Be honest about your annual mileage, select the slab wisely, and know the telematics rules and don't just look at the discount. If the numbers are correct, it is a fair price to pay for the risk you actually take.
Own damage cover is important even if you don't drive much because a parked car is still subject to fire, flood and theft. Each year you delay in checking your policy, you could be paying for kilometres you don't drive.
Call Simpli Insure today. We are an IRDAI-registered direct broker for life and general insurance with pre- and post-purchase support and claim assistance. Our advisors will compare policies and usage-based policies for your car and help you decide which one is best for you. Contact +91 95133 55661 and be protected before the next claim.
Disclaimer: This information is not a form of financial or insurance advice. Insurers may offer different usage-based products and the terms are subject to change. Before purchasing, please seek advice from a licensed insurance advisor and read all the terms and conditions of the policy. Insurance is a subject matter of solicitation.