Sign up with Google
Sign in with Zoho
Maria opened her boutique fitness studio in West Hollywood, intending to manage SEO herself. The question was, how difficult could this be? Six months and $12,000 of lost revenue later, she had an answer.
We tracked the DIY experience (of Maria and 5 other LA small businesses) to find out the actual cost of "going it alone." What we found was surprising.
Months 1-2: The Learning Curve Mountain
Maria spent 15 hours per week watching YouTube videos and reading SEO blogs. She put in $1,800 (at $30/hour opportunity cost) worth of time and at the same time, her studio was ranked #47 for the search term "fitness classes West Hollywood."
The competition was 3 blocks away from her, SoulCycle, who is working with a digital marketing company in L.A and has the #2 rank for the same search term.
The outcome of all the DIY efforts had moved Maria from position #47 to position #43 — a move of four positions in two months.
The Tool Trap (Months Three and Four)
Maria believed that purchasing tools would help her improve her search engine ranking so she tried several tools and subscribed to:
- SEMrush ($119/month)
- Ahrefs ($99/month)
- Local citation tools ($79/month)
- Rank tracking ($49/month)
Total monthly cost: $346 & her Google Business Profile ranking actually dropped to 51st place after she incorrectly optimised her Google Business Profile.
Hidden Costs No One Talks About
*Opportunity cost in time*: Maria spent on average 12 hours a week on SEO-related tasks for a total of 312 hours (over 6 months) that she could have used to train clients & develop programs.
*Mistake recovery cost*: After accidentally deleting important pages as the result of a “site optimisation,” Maria had to pay a developer $800 to recover her site.
*Mental bandwidth*: “I was so stressed about keywords and backlinks that I lost focus on my actual business,” said Maria.
What Professional Los Angeles SEO Looks Like
At the same time, we have tracked three different businesses using affordable local SEO services:
- Pilates Plus in Santa Monica – hired a local SEO agency at $800/月
- Ranked #3 for 'pilates santa monica' within 90 days
- 340% increase in organic leads
- 4.2x ROI over six months
- CrossFit Venice - $650/month SEO investment
- Dominated the local pack for 'crossfit near me'
- Membership inquiries up by 280%
- 5.1x ROI
Hard Numbers for Maria
- DIY Cost (for 6 months) for Maria
- Time cost was $9,360 (312 hours @ $30/hour)
- SEO Tools cost was $2,076
- Recovering from Mistakes Cost was $800
- Total = $12,236
Results: Moved from #47 position to #39 position (8 positions) versus an affordable local SEO service
Affordable local SEO service $4,800 ($800/month for 6 month's)
Typical results were top 5 ranking with over 200% increase in leads
Net savings = $7,436
The Moment of Truth
At the end of five months, Maria experienced the moment of truth. A new competitor just two blocks away outperformed her by utilizing professional Los Angeles SEO for their SEO ranking. Within 30 days, they achieved a #4 ranking for all the keywords that Maria was targeting.
Maria stated, "I finally began to see that I had been 'penny-wise and pound-foolish' and, in trying to save money, had lost customers."
The Change
The sixth month went better for Maria. She decided to hire a digital marketing agency in Los Angeles. After 60 days:
- Ranked #6 for "fitness classes West Hollywood"
- Optimising Google Business Profile
- 190% Increase in Website Inquiries
- 45% Increase in New Member Registrations
Conclusion
Do-it-yourself search engine optimization isn't just costly; it is an opportunity cost in disguise. While Maria was struggling for six months to do DIY SEO, her competitors who hired professionals were capturing the potential market customers.
The numbers are pretty straightforward:
The cost to do SEO DIY was $12,236 and six months of poor rankings.
The cost to hire a professional to do SEO was $4,800 and a two- to three-month wait for good rankings.
Total savings from hiring a professional to do the SEO were $7,436, plus one to three months wait time.
To LA Business Owners
Your time is worth a lot of money. Every hour you spend trying to figure out how to create your own DIY SEO is another hour you are not working on growing your business. There are some affordable local SEO service options available because companies can provide better results faster and at a lower cost than you can create your own DIY SEO.
The question is not whether you can afford to pay for professional SEO; it is whether you can afford not to invest in professional SEO.
Are you ready to abandon your do-it-yourself experiment? Your competitors aren't going to wait for you!
